We’ve taken steps to make Jonathan's Favorite with more natural ingredients. The colors may look a little less vibrant now, but the taste is just as good — if not better!
Discover the licorice that’s earned a special place in the heart of one of our founders. Jonathan’s Favorite combines the bold, chewy goodness of classic black licorice with a delicious pastel-colored candy shell. It’s a must-try for anyone who shares Jonathan’s love for unique and nostalgic licorice!
Receive exclusive perks that can be used across our entire family of stores (a total of 8 right now)!
Now only $9.95 per year!
Overall rating: 4.710059 / 5 from 1352 reviews.
Jonathan's Favorite offers a nostalgic treat with bold, chewy black licorice encased in a pastel candy shell. Customers praise its great flavor, perfect size, and outstanding quality. Fast shipping and rave reviews about the packaging and coating add to its appeal.
Review topics: [size, flavor, bite, problem, sweetness, quality, shipping, service, price, gift, packaging, order, variety, treat, favorite, licorice, crunch, mix, texture, candy, box, blend, husband, coating, sugar, mouth, quantity, colors, cinnamon, assortment].
"I bought these for my wife. She loves black licorice and these really taste wonderful. Sweet crunchy outside coating and chewy delicious black licorice on the inside. These will definitely be on our list in the near future."
"These are very tiny, thin pieces. You have to use a mouthful to taste the licorice. Other licorice products I have purchased here have been very good but disappointed with this one. Sent an email letting them know and got a $10 credit on next purchase?? I have spent a few hundred from this company so unless they are paying for shipping they should replace with something acceptable."
"My wife and I particularly enjoyed Adam's Favorite, Strawberries and Cream, and, in particular Fruit Frenzy. I know we'll be ordering them again."
"Very Good Yummmmmm"
"Great stuff"
"Really good. And really plenty!"
"Great snack later in the evening. Love the taste and enjoy the aftertaste."
"Very good with light candy coating. l letting the licorice shine through. This one is a winner."
"Not my favorite thing I've gotten from licorice. com. Looks nothing like the photos, The candy coating is very thin in the licorice was not fresh at all. The only product I've gotten from the site that I haven't been completely satisfied with"
"Jonathan’s Favorite has always been my favorite too - until recently. My last 2 shipments has had a dull dusty grayish color. The candy is no longer chewy & flavorful. Can’t determine if it’s the recipe, the finishing process, or quality control? What’s happened?"
